FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Books, dissertations, abstract

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 2 | 3 ||

«Der Open-Access-Publikationsserver der ZBW – Leibniz-Informationszentrum Wirtschaft The Open Access Publication Server of the ZBW – Leibniz ...»

-- [ Page 4 ] --

One point deserves further discussion. Researchers often face a choice between various measures for the unionisation of a country. In particular a choice between union density and union coverage. The latter gives the share of employees covered by wage agreements and paid accordingly - irrespective of direct union membership. While it is generally difficult to decide in favour of either union density or union coverage to be included in a model, we prefer union density in our setup. We believe union density has stronger implications for the bargaining power of employees. For a union’s clout in labour conflicts it is of crucial importance how many actual members it has since this directly determines the finances available through membership fees and the manpower in strikes and lockouts.5 A general and not surprising result emerging from table 3 is that the Anglo-Saxon countries are characterised by low unionisation relative to the sample median and that the Continental European, in particular the Scandinavian countries have relatively strong union membership shares in total employment. Thus, the following “sample split” exercise can, with some exceptions, also be seen as a crude comparison of differences in labour share influences between the English speaking world and Continental Europe.

Turning to the results if we split the sample according to union density (table 4) we Using union coverage to divide the two groups yield a largely similar grouping.

–  –  –

find that poolability of slope coefficients for the capital/output (ln(k)) and the ln(T F P ) variable seems not warranted for the countries that are classified as having high union density. Pooled Mean Group estimates of both slope coefficients are significant, but insignificant Mean Group estimates point to large cross-country variations in those estimates. In contrast, all three estimates for the trade openness coefficient turn out to be significantly negative. Furthermore, a Hausman test does not reject the null hypothesis of poolability for this latter variable. In comparison to the full sample estimates, the MPG and MG estimates of trade openness are approximately twice as high in absolute value.

Findings for the low union density countries show some interesting differences. First, FE, PMG and MG estimates for ln(k) and ln(T F P ) are negative and significant. PMG and MG estimates are similar and a Hausman test does not reject poolabilty of the ln(k) and ln(T F P ) coefficients. Secondly, trade openness does not seem to influence the labor share in the low union density countries since both the PMG and MG coefficients are not significantly different from zero. This casts doubt on the negative and significant static FE estimate.

It is important to discuss the results reported in table 4 in comparison to our findings for the full sample estimates. Remember that we do not reject the poolability hypothesis for ln(k) based on the full sample estimates shown in table 2, but we do reject the same hypothesis for the high union density countries. Similarly, we find poolable coefficients for trade openness in the full sample, but not in the low union density country group.

This discrepancy can be explained twofold: on a more technical point it must be noted that the MG estimator is particularly vulnerable to outliers as it simply computes the average of the country-specific slope estimates. Consequently, its precision increases with N, the cross-sectional dimension. Given that our sample split estimates are based on rather small subgroups, insignificant MG estimates may simply reflect small sample problems of the MG approach which in turn leads to a rejection of the poolability hypothesis. A second explanation brings us back to one of our main concerns, namely the treatment of cross-sectional heterogeneity. The question whether to pool or not to pool is naturally linked to the sample under consideration. If we allow for more homogeneity within a given sample as we do when countries are pre-grouped by a certain homogeneity criterion (union density), we would regard tests on the poolability of parameters as more powerful than in a sample with relatively heterogeneous countries. In this respect, the findings on poolability and non-poolability of parameters in the split sample may be preferred over those from the relatively heterogeneous full sample.

The upshots of the analysis that takes the influence of wage bargaining institutions into account are the following: First, for the countries with low unionisation (or low institutional bargaining power of employees) we find a high degree of homogeneity with respect to influences on the labour share through the capital output ratio and technological progress. Furthermore, the trade channel seems to have no role in affecting the relative compensation of employees in these countries. Secondly, for the countries that are classified as having powerful employees in the bargaining process, the picture is more mixed. However, there is more evidence that the trade channel is more important and may exert more downward pressure on the labour share than in countries with less influential employee institutions.

To bring theory and the empirical findings together, recall our above considerations with respect to how trade affects the labour share. We argued that the trade channel not picked up elsewhere is the possible power shift in the wage bargaining process. Now assume that any given change in trade openness might exert a heterogeneous effect across countries if there are different institutional arrangements. Our results point to stronger negative trade effects in countries with relatively many union members. A possible explanation for that finding may be the following. In countries where the bargaining power of employees is already low, or the wage setting process is simply not characterised by bargaining but by market forces instead, employees do not suffer a loss in relative compensation when the bargaining power of the employer increases, for instance due to an increase in a firm’s outside option. Put simply, if there is no union wage markup, the labour share is not vulnerable to shifts in relative bargaining power. In countries where the labour share was held at a higher level through strong unions, international cost competition and easier access of firms to the world’s labour supply brought down the labour share.

For the sample characterised by low union density, we also find the impact of the capital output ratio and the Total Factor Productivity to be poolable and to exert negative and visible influences. This may well hint at a stronger influence of technological change in those countries. Adjustments in relatives shares of factors used in production could be swifter and the effect of capital-augmenting technological change is visible in the labour share’s development. In the other countries, an organised workforce might better be able to shield itself from the forces of technological change. Yet, as argued above, globalisation makes this an ever more difficult task.

The above results emphasize the virtues of caution in the interpretation of the driving forces of the labour share. Even if one cannot technically reject the pooling assumption for empirical models of the labour share, this does not rule out important differences in the effects across countries or groups of countries.

6 Conclusion

The initial motivation for this paper was to shed some light on the key driving forces underlying the downward movement in labour shares across a variety of countries. More precisely, it was about assessing whether the explanatory variables exert the same influences in all countries; we wanted to test the pooling assumption on slope-homogeneity implied by almost all existing studies on the topic. For this purpose, we estimated the determinants of labour share movements with standard fixed effects models as well as in a dynamic heterogeneous panel framework. The latter allowed us to employ estimators which differ in their assumptions on slope-homogeneity and to subsequently compare the results. Based on those PMG and MG estimators we find the pooling assumption to be valid for two variables - the capital output ratio and trade openness. This first finding lends important support to the theory on labour share movements along the lines of Bentolila and Saint-Paul (2003). However, as far as other explanatory variables often found in the literature go, the picture is more mixed. Total Factor Productivity, in particular, is found to have heterogeneous slope coefficients across countries and no clear support for the pooling assumption is found.

In order to add more detail to our analysis and to address the role of institutional arrangements, we test for possible clusters among countries characterised by differently strong unions from which we assume implications for the wage bargaining process. We find important differences in the coeffcient values and levels of significance. For more market-oriented countries with lower union density, we see the labour share being driven by variables capturing technological change and shifts in the relative usage of factors of production. For countries with strong unions, however, we find trade openness to be the most relevant explanatory factor for downward movements of the labour share. We conclude this is due to trade openness reducing the possibilities of unionised employees to secure a wage markup in the distribution of factor incomes.

Given the above results, we conclude that further research as well as scientific policy advise should take possible slope-heterogeneity and institutional arrangements into account when estimating models describing the labour share.

References Arpaia, A., Pérez, E., and Pichelmann, K. (2009). Understanding labour income share dynamics in Europe. European Commission Economic Papers, (397).

Atkinson, A. (2009). Factor shares: the principal problem of political economy? Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 25(1):3–16.

Bentolila, S. and Saint-Paul, G. (2003). Explaining movements in the labor share.

Contributions to Macroeconomics, 3(1).

Binder, M. and Bröck, S. (2006). On the relation between investment and economic growth: New cross-country empirical evidence. Mimeo, Goethe University Frankfurt.

Blanchard, O. and Giavazzi, F. (2003). Macroeconomic Effects of Regulation and Deregulation in Goods and Labor Markets. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(3):879–907.

Buch, C. M., Monti, P., and Toubal, F. (2008). Trade’s impact on the labor share:

Evidence from german and italian regions. IAW Discussion Papers 46, Institut für Angewandte Wirtschaftsforschung (IAW).

Checchi, D. and Garcia-Peñalosa, C. (2008). Labour market institutions and income inequality. Economic Policy, 23(56):601–649.

Gollin, D. (2002). Getting income shares right. Journal of Political Economy, 110(2):458– 474.

Guscina, A. (2006). Effects of globalization on labor’s share in national income. IMF Working Paper, 06/294.

Harrison, A. (2002). Has Globalization Eroded Labor’s Share? Evidence from CrossCountry Data. manuscript UC Berkeley.

Hutchinson, J. and Persyn, D. (2009). Globalisation, concentration and footloose firms:

in search of the main cause of the declining labour share. LICOS Discussion Paper Series, (229/2009).

Jaumotte, F. and Tytell, I. (2007). How Has the Globalization of Labor Affected the Labor Income Share in Advanced Countries? IMF Working Paper, 07/298.

Pesaran, M., Shin, Y., and Smith, R. (1999). Pooled Mean Group Estimation of Dynamic Heterogeneous Panels. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 94(446):621– 622.

Pesaran, M. H. (2006). Estimation and inference in large heterogeneous panels with a multifactor error structure. Econometrica, 74(4):967–1012.

Pesaran, M. H. and Smith, R. (1995). Estimating long-run relationships from dynamic heterogeneous panels. Journal of Econometrics, 68(1):79–113.

Visser, J. (2009). The ICTWSS database: Database on institutional characteristics of trade unions, wage setting, state intervention and social pacts in 34 countries between 1960 and 2007.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 2 | 3 ||

Similar works:

«Name:* Kevin H.Land: Zeitraum: VAE 01.09.2013 – 09.02.2014 Studienfächer: Gastinstitution United Arab Emirates WirtschaftsUniversity wissenschaften ForschungsArbeitsgebiet: Schwerpunkt: Finance & Accounting ( * diese Angabe ist freiwillig! ) Datum: 31.01.2014 DAAD-PROMOS – E R F A H R U N G S – B E R I C H T Zu meiner Person Mein Erfahrungsbericht ist aus der Perspektive eines männlichen Studenten, mit diversen vorherigen Auslandserfahrungen, geschrieben. Dementsprechend sind meine...»

«Untapped Resources! Amazing Potential! TeNeT's Rural BPO Initiative Saloni Malhotra[l], P.Rathi[2], Timothy A. Gonsalves[2], Ashok Jhunjhunwala[2], Thejus Giri' 1 DesiCrew Solutions(P) Ltd., 2 TeNeT Group of IIT Madras, 3 Nilgiri Networks(P) Ltd., Ooty Abstract: DesiCrew is a unique Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) initiative that provides high volume data related services at an affordable cost from rural areas across India. The model provides cost cutting alternatives to urban clients and...»

«Fachbereich 7 Universität Bremen · FB 7 LS Controlling · Hochschulring 4 · 28359 Bremen Wirtschaftswissenschaft Lehrstuhl für Allgemeine Betriebswirtschaftslehre, Unternehmensrechnung und Controlling Prof. Dr. Jochen Zimmermann Sekretariat rewesek@uni-bremen.de Hochschulring 4 WiWi-Gebäude Datum: 31.01.12 28359 Bremen www www.controlling.uni-bremen.de Bachelorarbeiten: Themenliste Im Folgenden finden Sie beispielhaft Themen, die für Bachelor-Arbeiten am Lehrstuhl für...»

«© 2011 Sacred Economics | Charles Eisenstein Deutsch http://sacred-economics.com/ All content on this site is under a Creative Commons Copyright. Feel free to copy and share. © 2011 Sacred Economics | Charles Eisenstein Designed by Wpshower/ Powered by WordPress © 2011 Sacred Economics | Charles Eisenstein About Charles I will give you some of my background, although the intense transitions of the last few years have left me feeling like a new person. Hmm, I wrote that sentence two years...»

«Enterprise publications Observatory of European SMEs 2002 / No 6 High-tech SMEs in Europe European Commission Observatory of European SMEs 2002, No. 6 High-tech SMEs in Europe This report has been prepared from information provided by all partners of the European Network for SME Research ENSR (see Annex II) and was coordinated by Ms. Ulla Hytti, and D.Sc. Jarna Heinonen from the Small Business Institute, Turku School of Economics and Business Administration, the Finish partner and Mr. Thomas...»

«International Journal of Advanced Research in Computer Science Engineering and Information Technology Volume: 3 Issue: 1 26-Jun-2014,ISSN_NO: 2321-3337 Data Leakage Prevention System by Context based Keyword Matching and Encrypted Data Detection Soumya S R1, Smitha E S2 Mtech Scholar, Dept. Of Computer Science & Engg, LBSITW, India 1. Asso.Professor, Dept.Of Computer Science & Engg, LBSITW, India 2.. ABSTRACT— Data Leakage is an important concern for the business organizations in this...»

«DATA QUALITY DIMENSIONS FOR INFORMATION SYSTEMS SECURITY: A THEORETICAL EXPOSITION (INVITED PAPER) Gurvirender Tejay, Gurpreet Dhillon and Amita Goyal Chin Department of Information Systems, School of Business, Virginia Commonwealth university, Richmond, Virginia, USA Abstract: Data is an important asset used for various organizational activities. Poor data quality could have severe implications for information systems security in organizations. In this paper, data is viewed as embodied in the...»

«Eine neue Form von Verantwortung im Management Existenzialortung und Legitimität im Kontext des neuen St. Galler Management-Modells und Issues Management DISSERTATION der Universität St. Gallen, Hochschule für Wirtschafts-, Rechtsund Sozialwissenschaften sowie Internationale Beziehungen (HSG) zur Erlangung der Würde eines Doktors der Sozialwissenschaften vorgelegt von Hauke Laackmann aus Deutschland Genehmigt auf Antrag der Herren Prof. Dr. Thomas Beschorner und Prof. Dr. Florian Wettstein...»

«Lama Thubten Shenphen Natur und Ethik Nature and Ethics Lama Thubten Shenphen, France/Frankreich (Audiotranskription1) As we enter the 3rd millenium, most of us understand that our planet is falling ill, and this illness is mainly due to human activities. While it should be our principle concern to respect earth and its resources while looking to the long term, industry and business, however, are looking only for short term profits and financial benefit. As technologies have developed very...»

«The Crisis and the Global South: From Development to Capitalism Hugo Radice Discussion Paper CSGP D1/11 Trent University, Peterborough, Ontario, Canada www.trentu.ca/globalpolitics Introduction1 2 Thirty years ago, ambitions for a New International Economic Order based on autonomous postcolonial development foundered on the debt crisis that shattered the unity of the Third World as we then conceived it. Today, rapid economic growth appears to have spread from East/South Asia to Latin America...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.book.dislib.info - Free e-library - Books, dissertations, abstract

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.